Explanation of the Process of Contemporary Iranian Painters’ Participation in Auctions

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 art university of isfahan

2 Faculty (academic staff)

3 educator Economics of Art University of Isfahan

Abstract

 
Iranian painters had a closed and uncertain market in the late 1370’s, and the social conditions were not satisfying for emergence of an active art –however, after a while these conditions changed and improved. As the result, from Ordibehest 1384 ,big institutions such as Christies and Sotheby's established branches in the Middle East (Dubai) which paved the way for the Iranian and Arab artists. Iranian artists did well in this local market and got their position in international markets as well. This was the first huge step for the modern art of Iran. Certainly, Iranian artists’ participation in international markets in the early 21 century was significant, mainly in terms of sales. This auction has had a brilliant effect on the fate of Iranian artists and has linked them to international markets. Following that the presence of Iranian artists in the Middle East auctions began. Artists cannot easily participate in auctions, unless they have achieved the minimum requirements and the conditions for participation in the auctions. Individuals and institutions such as gallery owners and collectors, consultants, auction specialists, as well as other factors are to allow the works of art to be auctioned and give credit and role to artists. Therefore, economy and trade of the works of Iranian artists became an issue for governors. It is very important to pay attention to the questions such as: what are the causes of the success of Iranian artists in auctions? Which organizations and individuals were responsible for this participation and how? The purpose of this paper is to study the process of participation of Iranian contemporary painters in auctions. In this study the reasons for the Iranian artists’ success in terms of sales as well as the influence of people on this achievement (individuals and organizations (were explored. The descriptive and analytical methods have been used and data are collected from discovering interviews. The results show that artists participating in auctions were affected by four factors: cultural capital, social capital, economic capital and symbolic capital. These four factors can play different roles together and could make wealth in different combinations, but the best combination that could save the artists at the auction, gives them credit. It is first to know the cultural capital of the artist (for example, artist's background, creativity, intelligence and artistry, quality and variety in the artist's works), and the artist's social capital is absorbed (for example, the permanent and continuous presence of the artist in the art world, the artist's communication networks, the artist's character, the press attention, the taste of the agents of the auction, ...), then turn into symbolic capital (reputation). Finally, the combination of these capitals created economic capital. This kind of combination is a natural and correct process for participation in auctions. Artists can earn other combinations to achieve easier economic capital, but these capitals make a disproportionate combination which leads to the artist's failure in the next auction. Of course it may be that in a short period of time, obtaining the unreasonable emotional record of an auction, but that will not be permanent.  Eight important groups considerably affect the cycle of art marketing: artists, inland gallery, dealer, inland counselors, external specialist, auction, external gallery and buyers. The most popular kind of participation of artists and artworks in auctions is through six categories of: artists, inland gallery, inland counselors, external specialist, auction and buyers.
The Iranian artists take part in sales events in two ways:
1-Direct participating which is too difficult and lacks the guarantees.
2-Indirect participating that provides the guarantees and almost permanent participation. In the indirect participation method, there are many ways to get the artist's work to an auction, so that the artist himself may be unaware of his exposure to the auction. In this article, 17 types of participation are discussed. One of them is direct participation and the other 16 are indirect participation types. Of course, there are other paths that remain outside the scope of this article. Among these 17 indirect contributors to the auction, one is more conventional and well-known than the rest. In this research, the aim is to study the status and trends of the artist's presence from the first stage of production to selling it at auctions and determine what the current trend is and what is really going on. 

Keywords


- Abdollahi, Mohammad Hadi, (2012), Econometrics Of Art study Econometric study And Analysis of the Economic Situation of Contemporary Visual Artists of Iran, Master thesis,Tehran, Shahed University.
-Akbari, Amin,( 2005), The role of social capital in partnership: The study of the impact of social capital politics, social(Case study: Farsang village of Saqez functions), University of Tehran, University of Social Sciences.
-Bourdieu, Pierre,(1997) [(1983)] “TheForms Of capital” in A.H.Halsey, Philip,Brown, Lauder Weus,Amy stuart(eds) Education, Culture, Economy society,London, Oxford University Press.
- Chatrzarin, Maryam, (2012), The study of Economic Approach to Painting in Iran after the Islamic Revolution, Master thesis, Faculty of Arts and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University
- Fakouhi, Nasser, (2003), History of thought and theories of anthropology, Tehran, publication of the Ney.
- Fine, Ben, (2007), Social Capital and Social View, Translation by Mohammad Kumal Sarwarian, Tehran:Strategic Studies Institute.
- Ghezari Khazari, Muslim, (2014),  Young curries, Critic and artist, Tandis magazine (2), No 256
- Ghroroneh, Hassan, (2011), Reflection of Cultural Capital in Organization Mirror, Tadbir Magazine, No. 217
- Hafez Nia, Mohammad Reza, (2011), Introduction to research method in humanities,Tehran, Organization for the Study and Compilation of Human Sciences Books of Universities (Position) Center for Human Sciences Research and Development(samt) Center for Human Sciences Research and Development.
- Hosseini, Mostafa, (2012), Investigating Economics Of Art  After the Iranian Revolution and the Impact of Social Change on it (With emphasis on the 80s.), Master thesis, Art University of Tehran.
- Hosseini, Marzieh Sadat, (2015), Situation Analysis And Trend Of Iranian Painting Participation In Internal And External Auction, Master thesis, Art University of Isfahan.
hellibrun, James& m.garay charles,)2004(, the economics of art and culture,cambridg
university.
-Huda, Shireen,)2008(, pedigree and panache (a history of the art auction in astralia). ANU e Press.
-Iain, roberson& derrick chong, the art business, )2007(, Routledge/ Taylor& Francics GroupLondon and New york.
- Jahanbakhsh, Zahra, and Quemin, Alain (2012),Compartive A Review of the Iranian and Egyptian Art Market, The Art of Tomorrow Journal, 28+7
- Morid, Mohammad Reza, Masoumeh Taghizadegan, (2010), Field Study in Painting Economics, The Imagination mirror. No. 6
- Moridi, Mohammad Reza, (2012),  Levels and Dimensions of the Painting Market. Tandis Magazine No. 200
Mohammadi, Farnaz (2006), Investigating the status of supply and exchange of artistic works, Master thesis, Tehran, Azad University.
- Pourhosseini, Behrang, (2014), What curators do not tell us, tandis Journal(1), No. 256
- Renani, Mohsen (2012), Ferdowsi, Cultural and Economic dariche Journal, No. 25
-Throsby, david, )2006(. handbook of art economics, macqarie university, sydney, australia.
-Wogget,Gabriele, (1993),”Social Capital” ,Rural Sociology,No:63
www.Tehran auction.com
-zorloni, alessia,)2013(, the economics of contemporary art(markets,stratgies, and stardom), labrary of congress control Springer.