Matching the Structure of Yusuf and Zulaikha Paintings with Qur’anic Concepts (Case Study: Paintings of 15th -16th Centuries AD/ 9th-10th Centuries AH)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Master Student of Islamic Architecture, Tabriz Islamic Art University

2 architecture faculty, tabriz islamic art university

3 PhD student in Architecture, Art University of Isfahan

10.22070/negareh.2023.17148.3151

Abstract

Surah Yusuf is the only Surah in the Qur’an that specifically discusses a narrative from the very beginning to the end and is called in the Qur’an as the Ahsan Al-Ghesas (the best of the narratives). Like many arts, painters also used this narrative in their paintings to create works of art. By Iranian painting (also called Negareh), it is meant illustrations created from the 13th to the 17th centuries AD (700-1100 centuries AH). This study also examined the paintings of the 15th to the 16th centuries AD (900-1000 centuries AH).

Goal: This study aimed to compare the very environment of Yusuf and Zulaikha paintings with Qur’anic concepts and to investigate architectural physical elements and narrative characters in verses 23-25 and 30-32 of Surah Yusuf. It also deals with the similarities and differences between the paintings. This subject is important because of the significance of Surah Yusuf in the holy book, and the extent to which it has affected the artists in the domain of painting; meanwhile, the components that painters have addressed outside Qur’anic debates were also examined.

Questions of this study are 1) How are architectural physical characteristics and narrative characters of Yusuf and Zulaikha represented in the 15th to the 16th centuries AD (9th-10th centuries AH)?  2) To what extent do these paintings match with Qur’anic concepts as regards this narrative?

Method: This study was descriptive-analytical and gathered data via documentary and library methods. The statistical population of the study consisted of six paintings of the Seven-Door Room Narrative and seven paintings of Egypt’s women cutting off their hands.

After analyzing the Qur’an, some verses were extracted from the book, and to which relevant interpretations of six credible interpretation books were compared. The analyzed verses include the story of Prophet Yusuf (Peace Be Upon Him) when he was at the Prince of Egypt’s house. Verses 23-25 recount the story of the Seven-Door Room and verses 30-32 tell the ceremony held by Zulaikha and the women’s cutting off their hands. Meanwhile, the components obtained were divided into two groups: 1) Components of architectural physical structure that investigate architectural elements, architectural decorations, and objects in the Seven-Door Room story including the Zulaikha’s palace with various courtyards and numerous rooms, Seven-Door locks, and all the walls, ceilings, and floor of the palace, depicted with the pictures of Yusuf and Zulaikha. In the story of Egypt’s assembly of women, the verses refer to the invitation of the women to a festivity in the palace saloon, the enclosed space, the internal room where food was cooked, and the arrival of prophet Yusuf into this room; 2) Narrative character components refer to humans, characters, and characteristics raised in the Qur’an. In the Seven-Door Room, with the presence of Gabriel and the escape of Yusuf, Zulaikha tears apart Yusuf’s dress from the back, and the story of Egypt’s women’s assembly refers to the presence of forty guests and the lecture of Zulaikha, also referred to in the Qur’an and interpretations.

Results: Concerning the Seven-Door Room paintings, this study indicated that out of all the examined paintings, the painting by Kamal Al-Din Behzad of Sa’di’s Boustan (15th century AD- 9th century AH) was found to comply more with Qur’anic concepts from architectural physical characteristics, while from the narrative character perspective, no painting other than the one available in Jami’s Masnavi of Yusuf and Zulaikha (16th century AD-10th century AH) matched with Qur’anic concepts. These concepts are also represented in other paintings. Concerning the painting of Zulaikha’s assembly and women’s cutting off their hands, the painting of Jami’s Panj Ganj (16th century AD-10th century AH), the painting of Zulaikha’s Assembly (16th century AD-10th century AH), Jami’s painting (second half of the 16th century AD-10th century AH), and Safavid Jami’s painting (16th century AD-10th century AH) were found to be more compliant with Qur’anic concepts in terms of paintings’ architectural physical environment. In the narrative character section, most components are depicted in the paintings; however, some components have not delved into all Qur’anic details, thus representing little match with the verses. In sum, both categories of the paintings saw their architectural physical elements richer than narrative characters in terms of focus on Qur’anic concepts. It is also concluded that artists had not depicted the story of Yusuf and Zulaikha only based on Qur’anic concepts, since their impressions and artistic tastes had greatly contributed to their works of art. Here, the painters added some elements like using a yellow-colored halo over the head of prophet Yusuf and dress colors to convey the stories and their concepts.

Keywords


Ansarian, Hossein. (2019). Translation of the Holy Quran, Qom, Aeen Danesh.
Ayatollahi, habibullah, khabari, Mohammad Ali, Tavousi, Mahmoud, Lezgi, Habibullah. (2007). Analysis of the story elements of the story of Hazrat Yusuf (pbuh) in the Holy Quran, Research in Persian Language & Literature, N8, pp 20-1.
Egdaei,Toraj. (2013). A look at the structural elements of the story of Prophet Yusuf (AS) in the Holy Quran, Persian Liturature Quarterly, N15, P 41-9.
Ghafourian Masoudzadeh, Mehnoosh. (2016). Analyzing and examining the images of Haft Aurang Jamis illustrated manuscript in the Astan Quds Razavi Libararys manuscripts repository, Astanehonar, N17, P 35-20.
Ibrahim Elassal, Ibrahim Mohamed. (2016). The Veiled face of prophets in the Islamic miniatures- application on illustrated manuscripts of XVI century in Konya Mawlana Museum, Journal of the General Union of Arab Archaeologists, N1, P 125-89.
Jahanyar, Azar, Ghazizadeh, khashayar. (2017).  Introduction and analysis of architectural motifs in the paintings of Yusuf and Zuleikha form Haft Orang jami edition of Mashhad School, Negareh Journal, N44, P 96-58.
Karami, Mohammad Hossein, Hagigi, Shaheen. (2009). Investigating the narrative structure of two narratives of the lyrical story of Yusuf and Zuleijha, Journal of Lyrical Literature Researches, N13, P 124-89.
Kashani, Mullah Fathullah. (2009). Tafsir Kabir manhaj Alsadegin fi Alzam Almokhalefin, volume3, Corrected by Agigi Bakhshayeshi, Qom, Navid Eslam.
Maida, Tadaosh. (2013). Masterpieces of Iranian art in Polish collectiond, Volum1 of images, Translated by Mehdi Maghiseh, Dawood Tabai,Tehran, Matn Honar .
Maida, Tadaosh. (2013). Masterpieces of Iranian art in Polish collectiond, Volum2 of articles and descriptions of images, Translated by Dawood Tabai, Mehdi Maghiseh, Tehran, Matn Honar.
Makarem Shirazi, Nasser. (1998). Tafsir Nemooneh,Volum9 ,Tehran, Darolketab.
Mirlohi, Parima. (2020).  Explanation of the concept of proof of the Lord in Surah Yusuf and its manifestation in Yusuf and Zuleikha Jami and the painting of Kamaluddin Behzad, Paykareh, N20,  P 22-13.
Mosalaipour Yazdi, Abbas, Ghasemi, Hamed. (2014).  Moral virtues and characteristics of Hazrat Yusuf (AS) in the Holy Quran and Torah, Quranic Doctrines, N20, P 174-149.
Motafeker Azad, Maryam, Paydar Fard, Arzoo. (2015).  Investigating the characteristic of illustrated manuscripts with an emphasis on the illustrated manuscripts of yusuf (pbuh) and zuleikha in the central library of Tabriz, Negarineh Islamic Art, N6, P 100-56.
Mozaffari Khah, Zainab. (2021). Investigating the position of complementary contrast and breadth from Johannes Eaton's perspective in Kamaluddin Behzad, Scientific Quarterly of Al-zahra University,                   N 1, P 116-102.
Mozaffari Khah, Zainab, Guderzi, Mustafa. (2012). Investigating space in Iranian painting whit an emphasis on a selection of Behzads works, Scientific Quarterly of Islamic Art Studies, N16, P 20-7.
Najafi, Mohammad Bager. (1989). Works of Iran in Egypt, German, Clan.
Najjar Shushtri, Ali ibn Ali. (1994). Tafsir Surah Yusuf, Edited by Mir Hashem Muhaddith, Tehran, Sadoogh.
Nikbakht, Mahnaz. (2021). Studying the color avd form of clothes in the paintings of Kamaluddin Behzad, pazhohesh dar honar va olom takhasosi, N1, P 22-17.
Nowruz, Nestren, Mousavi ler, Ashraf alsadat, Daneshgar, Fahimeh. (2019). Reinterpreting the discourse of painting (the story of Yusuf and Zuleika) and its three contemporary adaptations, Culture-Communication, N48, P 296-265.
Rabizadeh, Samira, Tabatabai Jebeli, Zohre, Piravi vanak, Marzia. (2019). Examining the meaning in Surah Yusuf and its expression in Iranian paintings whit the approach of explicit and implict meanings, Jelve-y Honar, N1, P 20-7.
Rahmani, Jabar, Zafari Naini, Sepideh. (2015). Interdisciplinary research in art whit Hirschs hermeneutic approach (research case of painting art analysis, Negare Yusuf and Zulikha), Kimiya-ye-Honar, N15, P 63-47.
Rajabi, Zainab, Pourmand, Hassanali. (2019).  Analysis of Yusuf and Zuleikha painting by Kamaluddin Behzad based on Gerad Genets theory of transtextuality, Kimiya-ye-Honar, N32, P 95-77.
Richad, Francis. (2004). Manifestations of Persian art in exquisite Iranian copies from the 6th to the 11th century AH available in the National Library of France, Translate by A. Rooh Bakhshan, Tehran, Ministry of Cultur& Islamic Guidance.
Sadeghi, Esmail, Agha Khani Bijani, Mahmood, Rezai, Hamid. (2012). Structural analysis of the plot of the lyrical story Oof Yusuf and Zulikhai Jami, Journal of Lyrical Literature Researches, N19, P 124-103.
Sadegi nia, Sara, Hesari, Elham. (2000). Examining the place of realism of tiling decorations of the Timurid period in Herat school painting (with a thematic approach to Behzads paintings), Scientific Quarterly of Islamic Art Studies, N29, P 252-229.
Semsar, Mohammad Hassan. (2000). Golestan Palace (treasure of books and fine calligraphy) a selection of painting and calligraphy masterpieces, Tehran, Zarin ve Simin.
Shackle, Christopher. (1995). Between scripture and romance: the Yusuf-Zulaikha story in Panjabi, South Asia Research, N2, P188-153.
Shaikhi, Alireza, Mohammadzadeh, Zainab. (2018). Examining the pagination of paintings attributed to Kamaluddin Behzad in Bostan Saadi's edition (893-894 AH) as a model, Negarineh Islamic Art, N15, P 27-13.
Tabarsi, Fazl ebn Hasan. (1973).  Tafsir Majmaol Bayan,Translated by Ahmad Beheshti, Correction by Mousavi Damghani, Tehran, Farahani .
Tabatabai, Allameh Mohammad Hossein. (1984). Tafsir Almizan,volume11, Translated by Mohammad Bagher Mousavi Hamadani,Qom, Bonyad Elmi ve Fekri Allameh Tabatabeyi.
Tursunpolatovna, Jumayeva Dilnoza. (2022). Fine Art in the Epics of Yusuf and Zulaikho, EPRA International Journal of Research and Development (IJRD), N12, P 20-16.
Ziyaabadi, Mohammad. (2013). Kalam Al- Noor Noor Al- Kalam, Commentary on Surah Yusuf, Tehran, bonyad kheyriyeh Al-Zahra.
https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/455023/(access date: 24/1/2023).
https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/452672/( access date: 24/1/2023).
http:// artang.ir/yusuf-and-zulaikha/ (access date: 11/8/2022).
https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:%22Yusef_Serves_for_Zulaikha_at_a_Feast%22,_Folio_from_a_Yusuf_and_Zulaikha_of_Jami_MET_sf57-51-39-241r.jpg (access date: 11/8/2022).
http://art.thewalters.org/detail/80063/egyptian-woman-overwhelmed-by-yusufs-beauty/(access date: 11/8/2022).
Volume 19, Issue 71
September 2024
Pages 201-220
  • Receive Date: 20 December 2022
  • Revise Date: 11 February 2023
  • Accept Date: 14 February 2023