Analysis of Visual Features of the Murals of Seyyed Rukn al-Din Mausoleum’s Dome based on Iconology Approach

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 MA in Art Research, Tabriz Islamic Art University

2 Assistant Professor, Faculty Member of Visual Arts Department, Tabriz Islamic Art University,

3 Associate Professor, Faculty Member of Research Institute of Cultural Heritage and Tourism (RICHT), Tehran,

10.22070/negareh.2022.15770.2967

Abstract

The dominant and fundamental element in a religious architecture is the existence of the dome element, which was built in different periods in different ways; sometimes simple and sometimes decorated with special plant motifs and geometric designs. Usually, the structure of religious buildings and the ornaments used in them have unique features and represent the culture of that historical period and the style of art and architecture of that era, and the motifs used in the architectural ornaments can be considered as messages. “Seyyed Rukn al-Din mausoleum” located in Yazd city is one of the religious buildings left over from the Al-Muzaffar period, and the ornaments used in it influenced many of the architectural works of the mentioned region. Seyyed Rukn al-Din built this as school of Rokniyya and after his death the usage of building altered to mausoleum. In this study the murals of interior surface of this dome were selected to be studied. The present research, uses a different approach from the conventional methods of studying architectural ornaments, to analyzes the various layers of motifs used in the ceiling murals of Seyyed Rukn al-Din mausoleum, and its purpose is to understand the cultural and political developments of Al-Muzaffar period in Yazd city, based on the study of the relation between form and meaning in this work. To achieve this goal, we used Erwin Panofsky's iconology method to answer these questions: 1- What themes do the ceiling motifs of Seyyed Rukn al-Din mausoleum contain? 2- What concepts can be obtained from the iconological reading of these motifs? The research method in this qualitative research is descriptive-analytical, which is analyzed in three stages according to Ervin Panofsky's iconological approach. Erwin Panofsky's method in reading images consists of three stages: the first stage is pre-iconographic description which deals with formal analysis, the second stage is iconographic analysis that determines the relationship between form and subject based on literary sources, and the third stage is iconological interpretation which interprets and identifies the inherent meaning of the work in the context created. This research is an applied research and data collection has been done using the field studies and the library sources. The conclusion of the studies illustrated: In the stage of pre-iconography description on the interior surface of the dome of this mausoleum, the formal features of the murals were described and it depicted that the used motifs include a six-pointed flower, a six-pointed star, a twelve-sided sun (Shamseh) and its divisions based on numbers five, six, seven and twelve are designed as the infrastructure of motif design. The ornaments used included arabesque traceries and Khataei flowers, Thuluth and Kufic calligraphy used in blue (ultramarine), and the colors are white, red, green and brown tonality applied with watercolor technique. Also, usage of gilding is observed. In the hidden geometry of the dome, seven rings were identified in the central Shamseh, five hidden rings in the geometry of the dome, and a total of twelve rings in the composition of defined motifs. In the second stage, the subjects and concepts related to the used motifs were categorized based on the library sources. According to these, the motifs include the identified subjects of monotheism and oneness of God, the Prophet of Islam (Mohammad), unity in plurality and plurality in unity, justice, the twelve Imams of Shiites, the seven heavens, the sacredness of the number of five in Islam (five principle of faith, five daily prayers, the five members of Ale-Aba), righteousness, illumination, fertility, authority and glory. In the third stage, the interpretation of these subjects and the relationship between meanings and forms in the cultural and social context of that period were discussed. Based on this method, it was found that the motifs used in this mausoleum, due to the time and the religious beliefs of the builders and architects, have their roots in Shi’a, and artists have tried to use various decorative elements related to Shi’a to express the beliefs in this decoration. So, they intended to highlight the glory of their Shi’a beliefs in the Sunni era of Yazd. From the way of applying and dividing the geometric ruling system under the dome, it can be understood that artists of this mausoleum were not only bound by the principles and aware of the themes and content of numbers, but also they predominated the system of the hidden geometry that was applied in these murals. In fact, the unity and multiplicity in unity, which is the basis of creation, is in line with the application of the intellectual foundations of the Twelver Shi’a, therefore, it reveals the strong Islamic-Shi’a thought in the motifs of the ceiling of the dome of Seyyed Rukn al-Din mausoleum.

Keywords

References

The Holy Quran
Afsharmanesh, Mansoureh (2015), introduction and analysis of the ceiling paintings of Seyyed Rukn al-Din tomb and Seyyed Shams al-Din tomb, Master's thesis. supervisor: Samia Omidari, Ardakan Faculty of Art, University of Science and Art, Academic Center for Education, Culture, and Research (ACECR)
Al-Saeed, Essam and Parliman, Ayesha (1377). Geometric paintings in Islamic art. Translated by Masoud Rajab Nia. Tehran: Soroush.
Alvandian, Elaha (2012), Decorative ornaments of Seyyed Rukn al-Din tomb (Rukniyeh School), Yazd, Islamic Art Studies, Vol. 17, pp. 45-60.
Amirhosseini, Morteza (2007), Hidden symbols in painting, Tehran: Aban Kitab Publishing.
Ansari,H.and S,Schmidtke, “The Shi’i Reception of Mutazilism II: Twelver Shiis, in The Oxford Handbook of Islamic Theology. Ed.Sabine Schmidtke, Oxdord University press, 2016, 196-204
Azhand, Yaqoub (2008). The principle of Khataie in Iranian book design. Negre scientific-research quarterly, number ten, spring, pp. 17-29
Bayadar, Hengameh and Tofighi, Peyvand. (2013) Mihrab Semiotics in Theosophy and Islamic Art. Spiritual studies. No. 11 and 12. 153-173
Birouti, Shahreh, Gudarzparvari, Parnaz, Bagheri Garmarodi, Amir, Hatam, Gholamali. (1400). Analysis of the bird symbol in the coins of the Ilkhanid period from the perspective of religious discourse based on Erwin Panofsky's pattern. Islamic Art, 18(43)
Biyabanpour, Mojtabi. Khari Arani, Majid (2016), Study of the concept of the seven heavens in the Qur'an with an emphasis on the opinions of Allameh Tabatabai and Sheikh Tantawi, Allameh Tabatabai's Andisheh Publication, Year 4, No. 6, pp. 53-80
Bolkhari Ghahi, Hassan (1384), the cosmological position of circle and square in sacred (Islamic) architecture. Fine arts. Number 24, March 2014
Bolkhari Ghahi, Hassan (2013). About the theory of Mimesis: the theory of art in Greek philosophy and Islamic philosophy. Tehran: Hermes.
Bolkhari Ghahi, Hassan (2016), Geometry of imagination and beauty, Tehran: Farhangsarai Honar publishing.
Burckhardt, Titus (1376), sacred art (principles and methods). Translated by Jalal Sattari. Tehran: Soroush.
Burckhardt, Titus (1376), The Eternal Values ​​of Islamic Art, translated by Seyed Hossein Nasr, Tehran: Office of the Art Department of the Islamic Propaganda Organization.
Chevalier, Jean. Grabar, Oleg (2009) "The Culture of Symbols", 4 volumes, translated by Soudabe Fadaeli, Tehran: Jeyhoon
Critchlow, Keith (2008), Analysis of the cosmological themes of Islamic motifs, translated by Seyyed Hasan Azkar, Tehran: Hekmat Publishing.
Deis paul,(1952), le symbolisme dans la mythologie grecque, preface de G. bachelard, Paris,
Farhamand Borojni, Hamid. Esfahani, Abbas. Shishbari, Tahereh (2012), Identifying the materials and techniques of mural painting in five buildings of the Ilkhanid period of Yazd city, Journal of Restoration and Architecture of Iran, No. 4. pp. 97-111.
Farhangpour, Yasmin (2019) How to use iconography and iconography in criticizing the work based on Panofsky's theory (Case study: Piero della Francesca's sacred conversation), Ferdous Art, first year, winter 2019, number 3
 Flamaki, Mohammad Mansour (2002). The origins and theoretical trends of architecture, Tehran: Space Cultural Institute
Ghelichkhani, Hamidreza. 2012. Zarafshan (Dictionary of terms and combinations of calligraphy, book arrangement and transcription in Persian poetry). Tehran: Contemporary Culture.
Hamzavi, Yaser and others (2013). Gilding of molded stucco ornoments in the mausoleum of Seyyed Ruknuddin, Yazd. The first national conference on the use of scientific analysis in archeology and restoration of cultural heritage. Tabriz: Islamic Art University of Tabriz.
Hamzavi, Yaser and Vatandoost, Rasool (2012). Technical study and investigation of the mural layers of the ceiling of the dome of Seyyed Rukn al-Din tomb in Yazd. Bi-Quarterly Scientific Journal of Islamic Art Studies, No. 13, pp. 111-124.
Hamzavi, Yaser, Vatandoost, Rasool. Ahmadi, Hossein (2015) Investigating and understanding the nature of canvas wall paintings as a special style of Islamic architectural arrays in Iran/Islamic Architecture Research Quarterly/Number 13. pp. 148-130.
Hamzavi, Yaser. (1388). The project of conservation and restoration of decorative paintings and plaster decorations of a part of the dome ceiling of Seyyed Ruknuddin mausoleum. Yazd: Organization of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism of Yazd Province, Deputy of Cultural Heritage
Harris Susanna, Cecilie Brons, Marta Zuchowska(2022), Textiles in Ancient Mediterranean Iconography, Oxbow Books, United kingdom 2022
Hayat Nosaid, Reyhane (2015). Studying the types of Islamic motifs in gilding art of Safavid era. Practical project: Application of Islamic motifs in modern jewelry design. Guide: Eskanderpourkhormi, Parviz. Master's thesis. Tarbiat Modarres University
Jafari, Jaafar Ibin Muhammad Ibin Hassan (9th century A.H.)
Jalali Milani, Somayyeh, and others. (2019). Evaluating the possibility of using Ervin Panofsky's method in reading facades of historical houses in Iran. Bagh-e- Nazar, No. 17
Jobs, Gertrude (2015), "Culture of Symbols, Myths and Folklore", translation: Mohammadreza Begapour, Tehran: Akhtaran Publishing House
Kashmiri, Maryam (2016), "Illumination in Iran", History of Patterns and Terms, Tehran: Samt.
Kateb Yazdi, Ahmed bin Hossein bin Ali (ninth century). The new history of Yazd, by the effort of Iraj Afshar (1959) Tehran: Book Publishing and Translation Company
Keshmirashkan, Hamid (2016). An introduction to critical theory and thought in art history. Tehran: Cheshmeh Publishing
Khosrobigi, Hoshang and Sadeghi Fard, Mozhgan. (2017) Examining the foundations of the legitimacy of Al Muzaffar's government (713-795 AH). Journal of Islamic History Studies. 10th year Number 39. Winter 2017
Kianmehr, Qabad. Khazaei, Mohammad (2006), Concepts and Numerical Expression in Safavid Knotted Art, Kitab Mah Honar, No. 91-92.
Makinezhad, Mehdi (2016). The history of Iranian art in the Islamic period: the roles of architecture. Tehran: Humanities Research and Development Center Organization (Directorate) Humanities Research and Development Center.
Moshabaki Esfahani, Alireza. Safai, Narges (2015), the course of the emergence of plant motifs in early Islamic art (a special approach to Islamic and Khatai motifs), Negarine (Islamic Art): Volume 3, Number 10, summer 2015, pp. 32-40.
Mostofi Bafqi, Mohammad Mofidi. (11th century) Jame Mofidi. Try it, Iraj Afshar. 1340.
Mothaghali-Forosh, Firouzeh (2012), comparative comparison of the design and role of the mausoleums of Seyyed Rukn al-Din and Seyyed Shams al-Din, Yazd (Al Muzaffar period), supervisor: Seyed Hasan Soltani, Islamic Azad University.
Nasr, Seyyed Hossein (1366), Science in Islam, translated by Ahmad Aram, Tehran: Soroush.
Nasri, Amir (2013). Reading the image from Erwin Panofsky's point of view. Alchemy of Art Quarterly, 6
Nooraghai, Arash. (2008), number, symbol, myth, Tehran: Afkar Publishing
     Rajabi,F & Khosravi, M. (2019).  Formation of Geometric Patterns in the Architectural Decoration: An Investigation on the Ilkhanid’s Period. Journal of History Culture and Art Research 8(3):330-350
Samdanzhad Azer, Zeinab (2019) Comparative study of the technical and visual features of the stucco ornaments of the Soltanieh mausoleum and two mausoleums of the Al-Muzaffar period in Yazd (Seyd Rukn al-Din Mausoleum and Seyyed Shams al-Din Mausoleum), supervisor Farnoosh Shamili, Master’s thesis, Faculty of Visual Arts, Tabriz University of Islamic Arts.
Schimml, AnneMarie (2008), The Secret of Numbers, translated by Fatemeh Towfighi, Qom: Adian and Religions Publication.
Shayeshtefar, Mehrnaz. Kavian, Neda (2016), a collection of articles on the place of decorative motifs in the visual quality of Islamic art, Tehran: Islamic Art Studies Publishing.
Sheikh Al-Hukmai, Muhammad Ali and others (2021). The influence of the religious beliefs of the Ilkhans on the changes in the religious buildings of the 7th and 8th centuries of Hijri. Scientific Quarterly Journal of Restoration and Architecture of Iran. 11th year The twenty-sixth number. Summer 2021
Shekofete, Atefe and Salehi Kakhki, Ahmed (2013). The method of implementation and evolution of plaster motifs in Iranian architecture in the 7th to 9th centuries. Negrah Scientific Research Quarterly. No. 30 (Summer 2013). 63-81.
Shelomo, Jean Luc (2014). Theories of art: philosophy, criticism and history of art from the time of Plato to our days. Translated by Mustafa Gudarzi. Tehran: Saghi publishing house
     Trilling james,(2001), “the language of ornamant(word of art). London: thames&hudson.
Wilbur, Donald (1986). Islamic architecture of Iran during Ilkhanid period. Translated by Abdullah Faryar. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications.
Negareh Journal
Volume 19, Issue 69
April 2024
Pages 23-37

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 14 May 2021
  • Revise Date: 20 July 2021
  • Accept Date: 31 July 2021

Share

How to cite

Statistics