A Field Study on Pictographs in Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 ardabil: Ph.D. Candidate, Archaeological Department, Faculty of Social Sciences, Mohaghegh Ardabili University, Ardabil, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Conservation and Restoration, Isfahan Art University, Isfahan

3 Assistant professor of Research Center for Conservation of Cultural Relics,

4 Associate Professor, Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Social Sciences, Mohaghegh Ardabili University, Ardabil, Iran

10.22070/negareh.2022.16602.3086

Abstract

Pictographs are a visual representation of culture, mentality, and different human-environment interactions in an ecosystem. The art of pictography is historically one of the most common methods for societies to convey their meaning that has been featured on stone-rock panels and frames and they have been produced and reproduced like media from prehistory to contemporary times. The diversity and abundance of pictographs in most zones of the Iranian plateau highlight the fact that their pictographs need to be further studied. This is worth noting because most pictographs were made by illiterate individuals, groups, and communities in the past. Since pictographs were made in stone-rock environments, Isfahan province was a special place for this artistic representation. However, Isfahan has rarely been the subject of archaeological studies of art. Hence, the pictographs of Dombeh Mountain near Isfahan city are the subject of our study. Since there are no precise dating methods for determining when the pictographs were made, this study aims to recognize and thematically understand the motifs and narrative scenes and experimentally analyze the pictographs of Dombeh Mountain. The research questions aligned with our goals are: 1. what motifs are found in pictographs of Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan? 2. What is the drawing style of pictographs of Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan? 3. What are the constituent elements of pigments used in pictographs of Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan? 4. What period do pictographs of Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan belong to? And 5.What regions in Iran and cultural data can be compared to the pictographs of Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan? Regarding method, this is a qualitative and quantitative study by gathering data using field, experimental, and documentary research.
The results indicate that almost 90% of the human motifs were in front view, and the animal motifs were all in profile. Goats were painted more professionally, similar to their real anatomy. There were always two horns on their heads. Human motifs are mostly in front view in narrative scenes, including pastures, hunting, dancing, riding, etc. In ancient times, a ritual dance was performed during harvest or when praying for rain. In the study area, a ritual dance was performed during hunting as a thanksgiving ritual. Due to the regional climate, goats were mostly used as livestock by the local residents. Regarding the main pigment used in motifs of Isfahan, the result of analyzing red or ocher pigments indicates that they contain a high content of Fe, which is related to iron oxide or hematite mineral compounds, which is in red ocher. Furthermore, Al, Si, Mg, and K were identified in three analyzed sample points, which are usually found in clay compounds. These compounds, along with hematite, are the constituents of ocher pigment formed on limestone rocks.
The painted scenes on Dombeh Mountain narrate ranching, farming, and recreational hunting. In fact, the painter painted a completely naturalist and realistic picture based on the everyday activities of the people living around him which indicates the dominant way of living at that time. Motifs of Dombeh Mountain in Isfahan are all created in a realistic style. The creators painted the pictographs with a lot of precision and elegance, and they were perfectly able to represent human and animal gestures and movements while dancing, praying, or hunting. From an aesthetic point of view, the creator has tried to include as many details and characteristics as possible in each pictograph. Another interesting point is that the pictographs are located in an area with a desirable climate and a seasonal spring, which made it a perfect location for a farming and ranching lifestyle (semi-sedentary). The climate, water, and vegetation of the area turned the subsistence economy into a proper choice of living in the area, and thus, almost all the areas surrounding the pictographs depended on this type of living. Most probably, this living system was dominant in the area in the distant past, and the pictographs were made by semi-nomadic communities.
The investigations reveal that the pictographs are similar to other areas of Iran, such as the petroglyphs of Songon (Arsbaran), Bawki (Azna), Timreh (Khomein), Djerbat, Khore Hanjiran, Mahabad, Chalamber, and western Iran in terms of motifs (not the nature of the paintings). Regarding the dating of pictographs in Dombeh Mountain of Isfahan, animals and tools are noticeable. Comparing these motifs with the cultural information related to the Iron Age (e.g., horse, plow, bow, arrow, and yoke), the pictographs cannot date back to more than the 2nd millennium BC. Dating tools were used for the chronological analysis of pictographs in Dombeh Mountain of Isfahan in terms of morphological comparison to other petroglyphs and cultural information. Therefore, the pictographs can be cautiously dated back to the Iron Age, i.e., the 1st and the 2nd millennium BC, based on the animal motifs and the discovered tools.

Keywords

References

Aali, Abolfazl, 2012, Rock Art in Zanjan: Review of Rock Paintings in Zanjan: Review of Aqdash Mahneshan Rock Paintings. Payam Bastan-Shanas magazine, p. 10, p. 19, spring and summer, pp. 133-149
Abu Naim Isfahani, Hafez, 1997, Zikr Akhbar Isfahan, translated by Nurullah Kasaei, Soroush, Tehran
Adeli, Jalal, 2000, newly discovered motifs in Hemian. Cultural heritage, crafts and tourism of Lorestan province, unpublished report
Afshari, Hassan &  Bashtani, Marzieh-Al-Sadat, 2019, the newly discovered color motifs of the Humian people and its place in the life of the Kohdasht hills of Lorestan. Bastan-Pajuh magazine, year 19 and 20, vol 24 and 25, pp. 102-120
Afshari, Hassan, 2018, Documenting and examining the ancient patterns of color motifs of the Lashkurguiye rock shelter in Maymand, Kerman in 2018. The first conference on archeology and art history, Babolsar University.
Alden, J, 2015, Reviews book Nomadism in Iran, Antiquity, No. 66, Published online, 6 Aug
Ali Beigi, Sajjad & Khosravi, Shekoweh, 1999, Evidences of the social-economic institutions (?) of the Iron Age societies in the center of the Iranian plateau, Archaeological Studies, Vol 1, Vol 1, (consecutive 1), Spring and Summer, pp. 85-108
Amoozgar, Jhaleh, 2006, Mythological history of Iran. Address, Tehran
Anati, Emmanuel, 1998, writing on the wall, translated by Mohammad Eskandari. Journal of UNESCO Message, Q 29, No. 335, pp. 10-16
Anati, Emmanuel, 2004, Rock Art, translated by Mehran Hashemi. Book of Art Month, No. 71 and 72, pp. 111-118
Asadi, Ali (2007), Ashkeft Aho; A rock shelter in Bastak city (Hormozgan). Archeology Journal, New Period, Year 2, Vol 3, pp. 65-70
Askari-Khanqa, Asghar & Kamali, Mohammad Sharif, 1378, general anthropology, Address, Tehran
Bakhtiari-Shahri, Mahmoud, 2008, investigation and study of new petroglyphs of Dasht Tos, Archaeological Studies, Vol 1, pp. 44-21
Bartholimae, Chr, 1994, Altiranisches Worterbuch: Strassburg
Behbahani Irani, Homa; Behrang, Bahrami; Firouzeh, Agha Ebrahimi Samani & Saatian, Roya, 2009, Identifying the role of natural structures in the formation of the cultural landscape of the ancient settlement of Takht Suleiman using modern remote sensing technology, Journal of Environmental Science, Vol 36, No. 54, pp. 109- 120
Beik-Mohammadi, Khalil-Allah; Janjan, Mohsen & Nasreen Bey-Mohammadi, 2013, introduction and analysis of new petroglyphs of collection B of Lower Arges (Malair-Hamadan)", Archeology Journal, Vol 2, pp. 121-140
Beik- Mohammadi, Khalilullah; Janjan, Mohsen and Beik-Mohammadi, Nasreen, 2013, introduction and analysis of new petroglyphs of the Lower Barges collection (Malair-Hamadan). Archeology Journal, Vol 2, Vol 2, pp. 121-140
Bigleri, Fereydon; Moradi Bistoni, Alireza & Jamshidi, Fereydoun, 2007, report on the investigation of the motifs of Cheshme Sohrab cave (Maravoza), Dinur, Kermanshah, Ancient Studies, New Period, Year 2, Vol 3, pp. 50-55
Burni, Mak, 1969, preliminary report on the investigation and excavation of the caves of Kohdasht region, translated by Dzibah Allah Rahmatian, Iranian Journal of Archeology and Art, vol 3, pp. 14-16
Cassirer, Ernst, 1925, The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms, translated by Yadullah Moqen. Hermes, Tehran
Chevalier, Jean, Gerbran, Alan, 2008, The Culture of Symbols, Translation of Sudaba Fadaeli, vol. 4. Jihoon, Tehran
Dehkhoda, Ali-Akbar, 1971, dictionary,Tehran University Press, Tehran
Diakoneff, A.M, 1978, History of Mad. Translated by Karim Keshavarz. Payam, Tehran
Durant, Will, 1991, History of Civilization, translated by Ahmad Aram Moghadam. first volume, Islamic Revolution Publications and Education, Tehran
Farhadi, Morteza, 1995, Museums in the wind, introducing the huge collection of innovative petroglyphs of Timre, Social Sciences Quarterly, No. 7 and 8, pp. 16-61
Farhadi, Morteza, 1998, Museums in the wind. Publications of Allameh Tabatabayi University, Tehran
Farozandeh, Mahfouz, 2008, a research on Iranian dances from ancient times to today, Farhang Mardom Magazine, Vol 29 and 30, pp. 175-200
Farzin, Alireza, 1993, Lorestan in the passage of history, Publications of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Lorestan
Framkin, Gregoire, 1991, Archeology in Central Asia, Translated by Dr. Sadegh Malek Shahmirzadi, Publications of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Tehran
Fraser, James George, 1890, The Golden Branch of Research in Magic and Religion, Translated by Kazem Firouzmand, Agha, Tehran
Garajian, Imran; Adeli, Jalal & Papli Yazdi, Leila, 2010, The newly discovered petroglyphs of Hamiyan. Journal of Anthropology, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 84-100
Gardhan, Ezatullah, 1972, Marlik Seals, Marlik Magazine, vol. 2, University of Tehran, pp. 1-31
Ghorbani, Hamidreza, Sadeghi, Sara, 2015, Petroglyphs of the Central East, Chahar Tree Publishing, Birjand
Goff, C, 1970, Neglected aspects of Luristan art.Jaarboek van het Genootschap Nederland-Iran stichting voor culturele betrekkingen [Annuaire de la Société Néerlando-iranienne] 5, pp 27-37
Habibi, Mansoureh, 2001, Silk, Symbols and Symbols (Animal and Plant Patterns), Kitab Mah Honar Magazine, Vol 49 and 50, pp. 118-120
Hall, James, 2011, Pictorial Dictionary of Symbols in Eastern and Western Art, Translated by Ruqiyeh Behzadi. Contemporary culture, Tehran
Heydari, Mohammad, 2003, Saravan rock paintings, Gahnameh Avai Bastan, S. 2, Vol 3, pp. 2-48
Hossein-Abadi, Zahra, Safura, Xila, 2019, symbolic and religious foundations in the petroglyphs of the Saravan Valley sculptors, Fine Arts - Visual Arts, Vol 25, Issue 2, Summer, pp. 65-74
Insol, Timoni, 2012, Archeology of religion and ritual. Translated by Vahid Askarpour, Parse book translation and publishing company, Tehran
Izad Panah, Hamid, 1969, prehistoric paintings in the caves of Lorestan, Iranian Journal of Archeology and Art, vol 3, pp. 6-13
Izadpanah, Hamid, 1969, Doshe Cave Paintings. Archeology and Art of Iran, Vol 4, pp. 53-57
Jafari-Dehaghi, Mahmoud, 2012, The Myth of Rainmaking in Ancient Iranian Mythology, Iranian Studies, Vol 2, No. 4, pp. 53-60
Kolman, Hovar, 1984, Iran and Iranian Civilization, translated by Hassan Anoushe. Amirkabir, Tehran
Labaf Khaniki, Rajab Ali &  Bashash, Rasul, 1373, Lakh Mazar petroglyphs in Birjand, series of research articles, Tehran, publication series of National Art Association
Linton, Ralph, 2008, The Course of Civilization. Translated by Parviz Marzban. Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company, Tehran
Long, Julian, beta,The evolution of culture, Translated by Bijan Daneshvar, Guntberg, Tehran
Maqsodi, Mehran; Fazli-Nashli, Hassan; Azizi, Qasim; Gilmore, Gavin & Schmidt, Armin, 2011, The role of conifers in the distribution of prehistoric settlements from the point of view of geology and archeology (case study: Jajroud and Haji Arab conifers), Natural Geography Research, Q 44, Vol 4, pp. 1 -22
Mehrafarin, Reza, 1996, investigation of the cultural signs of animal motifs on the cylinder seals of Ilam. Master's thesis in archeology, historical period, Faculty of Humanities, Tarbiat Modares University
Mohammadian, Fakhreddin; Sharif-Kazemi, Khadijah & Mehrafarin, Reza, 2018, reflecting on the role of bow and arrow in the history and culture of Iran. Two scientific quarterly journals of art research. Q9. Vol 17, pp. 33-46
Mohammadi-Far, Yaqub, Hemti-Azandriani, Ismail, 2013, introduction and analysis of Azandrian Melair rock carvings, Social Sciences Quarterly, Vol. 64, Spring, pp. 223-252.
Mohammadi-Qasrian, Sirvan, Naderi, Rahmat, 2006, investigation and study of the rock carvings of Khara Hanjiran (Mahabad), Journal of Ancient Research, Vol 2, No. 3, pp. 61-64
Mohammadi-Qasriani, Sirvan, 2014, rooting in the modern tradition of writing monuments in Iranian petroglyphs, Payam Bastan-Shanas, S. 12, No. 24, pp. 115-124
Mullah Salehi, Hekmat Elah; Saeedpour, Mohammad; Momeni, Atusa; and Bahramzadeh, Mohammad, 1386, Archeology of rock paintings in the southern mountains of Qazvin province, Journal of Archeology, Vol 2, No. 3, pp. 35-49
Naseri Fard, Mohammad, 2007, rock museums, rock art. Navai Danesh Publishing House, Arak
Noorollahi, Ali, 2015, Rock paintings of Yazlichai, Gandam-kouh and Zaghram, Jestarha (Diyar), S. 1, Vol 1, Spring, pp. 113-85 White, Leslie A, 2018, The Evolution of Culture, translated by Fariborz Majidi, Nosle Aftab Publication, Tehran
Otte, M, Adeli, J & Remacle, L, 2003, Art rupestre de I oust iranien. West Iranian Rock Art, INORA (International Newsletter on Pock Art) 37, pp 8-12
Pordavoud, Ebrahim, 1966, Saddle, Bow and Arrow (a leaf from the history of weapons in Iran). Journal of historical studies. Vol 7, pp. 29-45
Pordawood, Ibrahim, 2002, Notes of Ghats. Asatir Publishing House, Tehran
Pourkrim, Hoshang, 1975, Jaft, Traditional Agricultural Production Unit in Iran, Anthropology and Popular Culture of Iran, Vol 2, Autumn, pp. 27-39
Qasimi, Taher, 2006, report on the study of Oraman rock motifs. Journal of Archaeology, Year 2, Vol 3, pp. 71-80
Rafifar, Jalaluddin, 2005, Arasbaran petroglyphs, Institute of Anthropology, Cultural Heritage and Tourism Organization, Tehran
Rashidi-Nejad, Massoud; Delfani, Maryam & Sotafi Zadeh, Narges, 2008, Introducing the petroglyphs of Djerbat, Jajarm city, Modares Archaeological Researches, Vol 1, No. 2, pp. 166-174
Rezaei, Munireh, 2014, Feasibility of implementing an agritourism project in Najvan Natural Park, Isfahan, Master's thesis, Isfahan University of Arts, Isfahan
Rousseau, Pierre, 1967, History of Industries and Inventions, translated by Hassan Safari. Amir Kabir, Tehran
Sabzi, Musa, Hemti-Azandriani, Ismail, 2019, review and analysis of Borujerd petroglyphs, Lorestan province, Archaeological Researches, vol. 2, period 10, summer, pp. 91-112
Sadeghi, Sara & Faizi, Farzad, 2021, The new paintings of gold petroglyphs of Qorveh in Kurdistan, Volume 42, Vol 4, Winter, pp. 488-504
Sadeghi, Sara & Ghorbani, Hamidreza, 2017, Investigation of human motifs in the carvings of eastern Iran, Khorasan Cultural and Social Studies Quarterly, Vol 12, Vol  4, Vol 48, Summer, pp. 122-91
Sadeghi, Sara & Rahimi, Saeed, 2019, Cups of Iran (Kurdistan Province), Aindegan publishing house, Tehran
Sadeghi, Sara, 2018, a methodical and scientific archaeological-anthropological study of the inscriptions of Kurdistan province (to achieve an index role for chronology). General Department of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism of Kurdistan Province: Unpublished
Sadeghi, Sara, Jovanmardzadeh, Ardeshir, Faizi, Farzad & Rahimi, Saeed, 2021,  traces of shamanism in the rock art of western Iran; (Case study: Kurdistan's gilded petroglyphs), Visual and Applied Arts Journal, Volume 14, Issue 34, Series 34, Winter, pp. 41-65
Sadeghi, Sara; Ghorbani, Hamidreza; and Hashmi-Zoraj-Abad, Hassan, 2014, investigation of Aso petroglyphs in Birjand city, Khorasan Social Cultural Studies Quarterly, Vol 9, Vol 3, Vol 36, Summer, pp. 75-96
Sanai, Majdod bin Adam, 1995, Hadiqa-al-Haqiqah and Sharia-al-Tariqah, corrected by Modares Razavi. Tehran University Press, Tehran
Sarhaddi, F, 2013, Pictograph and Petroglyphs of Saravan (Sistan-Baluchistan .Iran), Ancient Asia,  4,3, pp. 1.8
Sarkhosh Curtis, V. & Simpson, S. T. J, 1997, Archaeological News from Iran, IRAN, Vol XXXV, pp. 137-44
Shapourshehbazi, Alireza, 1376, Horses and Horsemen in Ancient Iran, Archeology and History Journal, Q. 11, Vol 1 and 2, Autumn, pp. 27-40
Sheikh Akbarizadeh, Samira; Amirhajilo, Saeed & Arab, Hassan Ali, 2013, an interpretive study of the new rock paintings of Zah-Klot Jazmurian, Iranian Studies, Vol 12, Vol 24, Autumn and Winter, pp. 195-215
Shidrang, Sonia, 1997, Meyole rock motifs; Novelties in the North of Kermanshah, Journal of Archaeology, New Period, Q2, Vol 3, pp. 55-64
Taheri, Sadr al-Din, 2011, dance, game, drama, investigation of dramatic actions in pre-Islamic works of Iran, Journal of Fine Arts - Dramatic Arts and Music, Vol 3. Vol. 43, pp. 49-41
Taj-Bakhsh, Hassan, 1993, history of veterinary medicine and medicine in Iran, Tehran University Press, Tehran
Vahdati, Ali Kabar, 2010, Stone canvases: report on the investigation of two rock art collections in North Khorasan province (Jerbat and Upper Nargeslavi), North Khorasan: Publications of the General Department of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism of North Khorasan Province.
Vahdati, Ali-Akbar, 2009, Stone canvases: A report on the investigation of two rock art collections in North Khorasan province, Archives of the General Department of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism of North Khorasan Province (unpublished)
Vaziri, Alinqi, 1998, General history of visual arts. Hirmand Publications, Tehran
Vialo, Danny, 1998, Prehistoric Imagination. Translated by Ali Mensheri. Journal of UNESCO Message, Q29, No. 335, pp. 17-21
Wolff, Hans, 1993, Ancient Handicrafts of Iran, translated by Siros Ebrahimzadeh. Scientific and Cultural Publications, Tehran
Zakari, Mohsen, 1969, Mythological Codes: Horse in Mythology, Book of the Month of Art, Ministries of Culture and Islamic Guidance, Vol 85-86, pp. 154-158
Zutterman, C, 2003, The bow in the ancient Near East, a re-evaluation of archery from the late 2nd millennium to the end of the Achaemenid Empire. Iranica Antiqua. XXXVIII, pp. 119-165
Negareh Journal
Volume 19, Issue 70
June 2024
Pages 109-133

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 04 May 2022
  • Revise Date: 20 July 2022
  • Accept Date: 31 July 2022

Share

How to cite

Statistics