An Illustrated Tilework of the Qajar Era; an Evidence of Consolidation of Iran’s National Authority in the International Arena (Available at Victoria& Albert Museum)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 M.Sc of Islamic Art, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

2 Assistant of Islamic Art Department, Faculty of Art& Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University

3 Faculty member of the Archaeological ِDepartment,, Research Institute of Cultural Heritage& Tourism

10.22070/negareh.2021.14641.2795

Abstract

National authority is a kind of rightful power, governing all potentials of a nation and attaining an enormous part of its validation and identity in their culture, through different mechanisms such as art, because although art provides a kind of visual pleasure in its outward appearance based on the aesthetic elements, it has also the potential to convey messages and thoughts and display political and social necessities of its own era in its hidden perspective and deep meaningful layers. Thus, as Foucault believed, each artwork is the meeting of different political and social debates which may be investigated for the purpose of identifying and analyzing the hidden meanings of authority, power and sovereignty. In this regard, the present research, with a case study approach, has focused on a tile tabletop from Qajar era, a work by Ali Muhammad Isfahani, so as to answer this question: How and by means of which characteristics are the content-based layers of its figures and illustrations created to become a visual proof of consolidation of national authority of Iran in international arena and to display such meaning? To answer accordingly, studies were conducted with reference to reliable library-electronic resources and based on iconological criticism approach to elaborate on the way the meaning was given to such tiles. The analysis displays that if the national authority is based on these three elements: identity factors, sense of belonging to such factors and knowledge of such factors, the artist has carried out illustration and visual narration according to all these elements. In fact, the artist has not merely intended to display the identity factors and belongingness, but he had a comprehensive and extensive knowledge of them and has taken action in creating decorative drawings and figures, relying on such knowledge and comprehension for the following reasons:
1- From all verse, prose and folk stories which have always been reflecting the thoughts of the Iranians in ups and downs of historical events, the artist has chosen some stories which emphasize on political heritage of the Iranians and their victories against the enemies’ invasions more than the others. Therefore, he has chosen five stories from Shahnameh, three stories from Hosseinnameh and one from Ghahremannameh.
2- Whereas he was aware that Houshang is the first king of the world after Kiomars and the founder of mythical ages of the world, he has placed the illustrations of such characters on the head of the tabletop and has set that as a base for placement and sequence of other illustrations.
3- He has made endeavors to convey some messages such as honor, bravery, courage, patience, chivalry, compassion, generosity, loyalty, patriotism, sacrifice and defense in the framework of interests of Iranian nation, and to hide them under visual layer of his artwork, because he created this artwork in a situation when he was first, completely aware of the position of its orderer, Robert Murdoch Smith, and he knew that this tile tabletop would be sent abroad to the UK after its creation and delivery, and second, he had accepted such order at a time when a new period of endangering historical borders and territorial integrity of Iran was started.
4- Whereas he was aware that authority is not an abstract concept and that it will come to existence when it is considered proportional to each period of time, he has made use of the common technique of that period, which is underglaze painting with light and bright colors in forming the mechanism of his artwork. Although, in this regard he obliged himself to display such mechanism with Iranian and Islamic attributes. Therefore, he refers to the tradition of accompaniment with literary contents; exactly in the middle of the period when tendency to modernism and to disconnect from literature became popular following the west.  Further, he has made use of rules and principles of Persian miniature.
Thus, we can generally conclude that Ali Muhammad Isfahani has not just intended to display his antecedent through repeating the historical patterns in the exact same form, but he was completely aware of all identity factors such as history, geography and territory, political heritages and government and cultural and scientific heritages, and connected them to the visual elements of his artwork in line with a specific and purposeful orientation. In other words, he has institutionalized them as the meaningful layers of visual elements of his artwork to signify a proof of an illustration of consolidation of national authority of Iran in international arena in the form of a painted tile tabletop; narrating the interesting ancient stories of Iran.

Keywords


Abedini Moghanaki, Maryam, Fields of Continuation of Specialization in the Era of Shah Abbas II Safavid, Quarterly Journal of the History of Islam and Iran, 127, 2018, 105-124.
Afshar, Iraj, and Afshari, Mehran, 2006, The Story of Hossein Kurd Shabestari, Tehran, Cheshmeh Publishing.
Aidenloo, Sajjad, Notes on the Notes of Shahnameh 1, Ancient Iran Letter, 2, 2003, 39-71.
Ale-Ibrahim Dehkordi, Saba, The Role of Cypress Tree and its Symbolic Meanings in Paintings of Shahnameh Tahmasebi, Bagh Nazar Quarterly, 45, 2016, 105-114.
Barzegar Khaleghi, Muhammad Reza, 2000, The Demon in the Shahnameh, Tehran, Fekr Rooz.
Ferdowsi, Abolghasem, 1998, Shahnameh, Tehran, Sokhan-gostar
Gheibi, Mehrasa, 2005, History of Iranian Ethnic Clothing, Tehran, Hirmand
Hafeznia, Muhammad Reza, and Ahmadipour, Zahra, and Khojamli, Abdul Wahab, and Ansarizadeh, Salman, Representation of the Concept of Nation in Cyberspace, Quarterly Journal of Geography and Regional Planning, Preface, 2009, 1-25.
Hanif, Muhammad, 2016, National Identity in Safavid Folk Tales, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Publications.
Hojbar, Siavash, and Ansari, Bahman, 2001, Ghahramanameh, The Comprehensive Portal of the History Book [Online]
Hojbarian, Hossein, Historiography and Territorial Integrity of Iran, Quarterly Journal of Strategic Studies, 86, 2019, 117-154.
Ibn Balkhi, 1995, Farsnameh, edited by Mansour Rastegar Fasaei, Shiraz, Fars Studies Foundation.
Kavousi, Valiallah, The Beginning of Islamic Art Historiography in the Plant of Orientalism, Colonialism and Collectivism, Honarha-ye Ziba Quarterly, 94, 2019, 15-24.
Khodaei, Sayyed Ali Akbar, The Role of Culture in National Authority, Quaterly Journal Scientific of Strategic Defence Studies, 11-12, 2001-2, 75-84.
Makkinejad, Mahdi, 2021, Fanne Jamil (Ali Muhammad Isfahani’s Life and Works), Tehran, Iranian Academy of Arts.
Matin, Peyman, "Clothing and Ethnic and National Identity", National Studies Quarterly, 19, 2004, 37-48
Moein-Aldini,  Muhammad, and Assar Kashani, Elham, The Evolution of Natural Aesthetics in the Monographs of Isfahan School", Jelveh Honar Quarterly, 9, 2013, 77-90.
Mojtahedzadeh, Rouhaleh, and Saadvandi, Mahdi, A Look at the Discourse Developments in the Field of Islamic Art in Three Periods, Quarterly Journal of Islamic Art Studies, 28, 2017, 55-76
Murdoch Smith, Robert, 2020, Iranian Art, Translated by Kianoosh Motaghedi, Tehran, Calligraphy and Design Publishing
Nasrollahzadeh, Muhammad Javad, and Alizadeh, Mouhammad Javad, and Safdari, Salman, "Historiography and Territorial Integrity of Iran", Quarterly Journal of Strategic Studies, 86, 2015, 117-154.
Nowruzi Firooz, Rasoul, The Role of the Islamic Revolution and the Iranian Islamic Model of Progress in the Creation of the Iranian Islamic Civilization", Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 60, 2012, 55-81.
Piri, Musa, 2015, Study and Analysis of the Personality of the Goodarz family in Shahnameh, The first International Conference on Innovation and Research in Art and Humanities, Mobin Cultural Ambassadors Institute.
Qalibaf, Muhammad Baqir; and Pooyandeh, Muhammad Hadi, Geographical Explanation of the Foundations of National Identity (Case Study: Iran), National Studies Quarterly, No. 48, 2011, 3-24.
Rahbarnia, Zahra, and Ansari, Mojtaba, Special Databases for Analysis, Analysis and Critique of Visual Communication Works, Honarha-ye Ziba Quarterly, 16, 2003, 69-78.
Rahimi, Gholamreza, and Zabihi, Rahman, and Abbaszadeh, Somayeh, "Exploitation of the Widely Used Elements of the Myths of Kings and Heroes of Ancient Iran in the Poetry of Prominent Constitutional Poets", Quarterly Journal of Mystical and Mythological Literature, 25, 2011, 57-84.
Sadeghi, Ali, 2013, Controversial Study of the Kingdom of Houshang and Tahmourth, 7th Persian Language and Literature Research Conference, Ministry of Science, Research and Technology: University of Isfahan
Salami, Muhammad Mahdi, 2018, Overview of the State of National Dignity in the Qajar and Pahlavi Eras, Borhan Think Tank: 11/1/1397 [Online]
Sayyed Mousavi, Atefeh, 2020, The Communication of Safavid and Qajar Art from the View Point of Ali Muhammad Isfahani, Siah-Qalam (Research of Ali Muhammad Isfahani: His Life and Wrks), Try by Mahdi Makkinejad, Tehran, Iranian Academy of Arts.
Taghavi, Abed, The Place of Qajar Rock Reliefs in Restoring the National Identity of Iran, Quarterly Journal of National Studies, 60, 2014, 161-180.
Varjavand, Parviz, 1989, Progress and Development Based on Cultural Identity, Tehran, Enteshar Co.
Zarezadeh, Fahimeh, 2014, Strategies of Artistic Expression in International Cultural Relations of Iran (Case Study: Expo World Exhibitions), PhD Thesis, Art Research, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran
B- Sites