A Reflection on the Historical-Visual Developments of Iran in the Second Half of the Qajar Era, Regarding the Three Civil Roles (of Ulama, the Upper Class, and Women) in Conforming with the Murals of this Era

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Abstract

Studying history through images is a new approach to historiography, because most of the chronicles were expressed in the form of writing, and only part of information about the past may be visually presented. Images can serve as a basis for reviewing the scenes and essence of events, and, of course, a historical study where there is access to the visual documents is much more accurate than a narrative and written study. The visual arts were welcomed in the mid-Qajar era, and the arrival of the camera in Iran accelerated the process of visual documentation. Painting, also influenced by the West, gradually took a step further in the form of portraiture and image documentation alongside the camera. In the meantime, the social structure of the country evolved, influenced by the relationship with the West and modern thinking, and led to the enlightenment of the people in some ways. Following the dissatisfaction with the ruling power, the nation arose alongside the Ulama, meanwhile the influence of the Europeans and their influential relationship with a particular group of the society led to the growth of the upper class, and the women's community undergone transformations to allow for modern communications. The present article aims at investigating the effects of these movements on the content of murals in the second half of the Qajar dynasty and introducing these images as a historical-visual document to study the history of the era. This article investigates the subject by asking two questions: 1) what are some of the manifestations of the effect of society’s development and its modern visage on these murals? 2) To what extent can these murals be named as documents to study the history of this era? This research collects information through historical-interpretive method as field and desk studies, and compiles contents by collecting documents, writing, photographing and surveying the murals of this era. In this research, 73 tile paintings and 38 murals were investigated, which were selected on a case-by-case basis and based on a selective method regarding the research topic. This article presents 17 examples of these images.
  Based on the results, by studying the images of this period, one can clearly explore the trace of the three aforementioned streams. Due to their place in society and to be paid respect to, religious Ulama played a role in the murals of public and semi-religious places such as the Tekyeh Moaven al-Molk, with the distinction that in the murals prior to this era, no monograph theme can be observed by Ulama, and can only be observed in the form of images such as court and collective assemblies. Also women, who had a distinctive status, were depicted in the decorations of the palace walls and private mansions. At this time, the woman's presence in the pictures respects her character. The woman is now seen dressed in glittering dresses, jewelry and modern make-up, displaying a distinctive image of herself. The aristocrat social class was also associated with the Europeans because of their wealth, and in pursuit of showing off their wealth, they turned to art which had been neglected. Because of their familiarity with the Western world, as well as imitating the royal court and exhibiting their power through art, they gave rise to the formation of murals in their personal mansions, with pictures of foreign and Iranian women and men with distinctive structures. The princes and nobles who had never been seen before in such murals were now a new subject for drawing, and in some cases the Europeans who were associated with them were depicted on the walls of the nobles' mansions. In the past, if there had been an image of the Europeans, it was based on a diplomatic approach, and in most cases a courtship ceremony or some kind of copy of postcard images, however, it was now recognized as a new theme in these murals. The second part of the findings of the present study showed that visual history, and in particular murals, can be considered as evidence in the study of history. However, these examples can only be studied as complementary to the written documents, and can be relied upon to investigate the status quo of affairs of the time, which is distinctive by changing the coatings and selecting distinctive styles and using modern manifestations in them. Certainly, and based on the results of this article, the paintings alone are not capable of accurately expressing the history, as some of them have undergone changes in relation to the originality of the subject, depending on the painters' taste, and the painter also, influenced by his own community, has accepted the effects of society in creating images of the community. Many of these effects such as imitating the West are mentioned in the article.

Keywords

References

Aflaki Sooreshjani, Asghar and Sepehran, Kamran and Moridi, Mohammad Reza, Assessing orientation of painting system through constitutional revolution era, J Fine arts (Visual Arts), 22[1]; 2017: 107-122.
Afshar, Iraj (1971), Etemad Al-Saltanah Diary: Minister of Imprint at the end of Naseri Period, Tehran, Amirkabir.
Afzal Tousi, Effat alsadat & Selahi, Golnaz & Selahi, Ladan, Investigating tiles with Qajar women motifs in houses of Shiraz, 5[4], 2014, 577-594
Ameli, Seyed Reza(2013), Research Methods in Cultural and Media Studies, Tehran, University of Tehran.
Ansari, HamidReza and Heydari, Erfan, Reflection on evolution of culture and society of Iran in mid-Qajar era , following the link with west (To witness the wall paintings of Sarim Al-Dawla mansion in Kermanshah), J Fine arts (Visual Arts), 23[1]; 2018: 17-28.
Armaghan, Maryam and Soltanzadeh, Hossein and Irani Behbahani, Homa, Redefining, Woman’s Role in the Family and its Impact on the Painting Decorations and Structure of Aristocratic Houses in Tehran during the Qajar era, Bagh nazar, 12[34]; 2015: 103-116
Ashraf, Ahmad and Beno Azizi, Ali (2008) Social classes of government and revolution in Iran, Translated by Soheila Torabi, Tehran, Niloufar.
Bashir, Hasan, Iranian intellectuals and political discourse in the Qajar era, Journal first line, 2007; 3: 45-67
Bayat-Philipp, Mangol, Women and Revolution in Iran, 1905–1911, in Lois Beck and Nikki Keddie (eds.), Women in the Muslim World, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press. 1978: 295-306
Cole, I. R. Juan, Iranian millenariansm and democratic thought in the 19th century, Int. J. Middle East Stud, 24[1]; 1992: 1-26
Etehadieh (Nezam mafi'e), Mansoureh, 1998, Tehran, Iran: A Collection of articles about Tahran 1269-1344, Tehran: Publication of Iranian History.
Floor, M.Willem & Chelkowski, J.Peter & Ekhtiar, Maryam, 2002, Paintings and painters of the Qajar period, Translated by Jacob Ajand, Tehran: Il-e Shahseven-e Baghdadi publication
Foran, John(1993), Fragile Resistance: Social Transformation In Iran From 1500 To The Revolution, boulder co, Westview Press.
Foran, John, The concept of dependent development as a key to the political economy of Qajar Iran (1800–1925), Iranian Studies, 22[2-3]; 1989: 5-56
Groat, Linda & Wang, David (2013), Architectural research methods, Tehran, University of Tehran.
Heidary, Shahin(2014), Introduction to research method in architecture, Tehran, New Thought.
Heydarkhani, Maryam, Scientific report: Iranian painting as the source of Iranian architectural history, Joyrnal of Iranian architecture studies, 7[1]; 2015: 151-163.
Hojat, Eisa (2012), Tradition and innovation in architecture education, Tehran, University of Tehran
Jahanbegloo, Ramin (2005), Between the Past and the Future, Tehran, Ney publishing.
Karbalaei, Hasan (1982) Rig's contract, Tehran, warriors Publishing.
Kasravi, Ahmad, 1965, Constitutional History of Iran, Tehran: Amir Kabir
Kazemi Moussavi, Ahmad, The basis and nature of Ulama's authority in Qajar Iran, Iran nameh, 58, 1997, 199-228
Kazemian, Seyyed Shahabeddin, The Relationship of Qajar-era Tehrani Ulama with Power and Modernity; A Review of the Political and Jurisprudential Works of the Ulama of the Qajar Period, Shahre Ghanoun, 6, 2013: 31-32
Keddie, R. Nikki, 1976, Tobacco Sanctions in Iran, Translated by Shahrokh Ghaem Maghami, Tehran: Amir Kabir
Keddie, R. Nikki, The Iranian power structure and social change 1800-1969: An overview, Int. J. Middle East Stud, 2[1]; 1971: 3-20
Keddie, R. Nikki, The Roots of the Ulama's Power in Modern Iran Studia Islamica, 29; 1969: 31-53
Khatoonabadi, Afsaneh, Poetry and painting in the Qajar period; A challenge between tradition and modernity, Contemporary Persian literature, 1[2]; 2012: 39-55
Khodadad, Masoumeh, The First Women Newspapers in Iran, Hafez Monthly, 49, 2008: 23-26
Majdol Malik Sinaki, Mirza Muhammad Khan(1942), Treatise of Majdieh, Tehran, Central Library of Tehran University.
McDaniel, A. Robert(1971), Economic change and economic resiliency in 19th century Persia, Iranian studies, 4[1]; 1971: 36-49
Mousavi Haji, Seyed Rasoul and Zarifiyan, Roya, The effect of the modernity wave and the renewal trend in the development of Iranian clothing (From the beginning of the Qajarrid Era to the end of the first Pahlavi dynasty), 6[1]; 2014: 193-219.
Muharrami, Nematollah and Mehraban, Hassan (2006), Collection of laws and approvals of national divisions, Volume one-1285 to 1363 AH, Tehran, Goharshad.
Nord, Paul David(1989), The nature of historical research, ch15 in research methods in mass communication, eds, by Gudio stempel & Bruce H. Wesley, Englewood cliffs, Nj: Prentice-hall.
Panahi, Abbas, The Social Role of Women in Tobacco Abolition, Shei' Women - Institute of Sheiology, 9 [28], 2012: 249-273
Pavlovitch, Michel, "La situation agraire en Perse a la veille de la revolution", in Revue du Monde Musulrnan, 12[12]; 1910: 616-625
Rosenstone, A. Robert, History in Images/History in Words: Reflections on the Possibility of Really Putting History onto, The American Historical Review, 93[5]; 1988: 1173-1185
Roshdieh, ShamsAl'ddin, 1983, life resumes, Tehran: Iran Date of publication
Royan, Samira and Samanian, Samad, A study in importance and operation of the illustration of history in Safavid era, Journal of visual & applied arts, 9[18]; 2017: 81-100
Saeidi, Golnaz, Women's Associations in the Constitutional Period, Political & Economic Ettela'at, 230, 2006, 316-325
Sanasarian, Elise, 2005, Women's Rights Movement in Iran, Translated by Nooshin Ahmadi, Tehran: Akhtaran
Scarce, Jennifer, Entertainments east and west-Three encounters between Iranians and Europeans during the Qajar period (1786–1925), Iranian Studies, 40[4]; 2007: 455-466
Seif, Hadi (2001) Persian Murals, Tehran, Soroush press.
Seif, Hadi (2013), Persian painted tiles, Tehran, Soroush press.
Shirazi, Mahmonir and Mousavilar, Ashrafosadat, Retrieval of Identity layers in Qajar Era (case study: ceramics), J Negareh, 12[41]; 2017: 17-29.
Sojoodi, Farzan and Ghazimoradi, Behnaz,  A study on Constitutionalism Discourse and visual norms in Qajar era, Sociological journal of art and literature, 4[1]; 2013: 93-122.
Torabi farsani, Soheila, "The Process of Women,s Education from the Begining of Moderization Efforts up to the End of Reza Shah,s Era", Daneshnameh Quarterly Journal of the Islamic Azad University, 87, 2008: 89-101
Torabi Farsani, Soheila, Women's Struggle in Qajar Age:  Individuality, the world of tradition and the transition from it, 19[2]; 2009: 1-23.
White, Hayden, Historiography and Historiophoty, The American Historical Review, 93[5]; 1988: 1193-1199
Woulfe Sheil, Mary Leonora (1989), Glimpses of life and manners in Persia, Translated by Hossein Abotrabian, Tehran, New publishing.
Yarshater, Ehsan, The Qajar era in the mirror of time, Iranian Studies, 34[1-4]; 2001: 187-194
Zarinkoub, Abdul Hossein (2015), History in Scale (About historicism and Historiography), Tehran, Amirkabir.
Negareh Journal
Volume 14, Issue 52
December 2019
Pages 85-99

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 22 May 2019
  • Revise Date: 14 October 2019
  • Accept Date: 13 November 2019

Share

How to cite

Statistics