Comparative Comparison of Geometric Designs of Kerman Jami Mosque with Yazd Jami Mosque with an Emphasis on Porches and Entrances

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assisstant professor, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Shiraz University, Fars Province, Iran

2 Art Department, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Shiraz University, Iran

3 MA Student in Art Research, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Shiraz University, Fars Province, Iran.

10.22070/negareh.2020.5092.2383

Abstract

Architects and artists have long been fascinated by the use of geometric decorations in the construction of buildings, especially religious buildings. In this paper, we have tried to compare some of the landmark designs of the two buildings of Kerman Jami Mosque (755 AH) and Yazd Jami Mosque (724 AH).
Kerman Grand Mosque is one of the 700-year-old four-porch mosques that have a lofty entrance, courtyard, porch and nave. Its construction began in (705 AH) by the order of Amir Mobaraz al-Din Mohammad Mozaffari Meybodi, the head of the Mozaffari dynasty, which ended at the end of 755 AH. Inspired by Sassanid architecture, its eastern entrance was destroyed by the firing of Agha Mohammad Khan and was later repaired. Yazd Jami Mosque has been built in the style of a porch in the heart of the desert during a century (the 6th century AH) in different historical periods, the most important of which are Ilkhanid, Safavid, Timurid, Al-Muzaffar and Qajar. Over time, it was built by several founders, but the main foundations of the mosque were built by the Sassanids. The current building of this mosque is considered to be Azeri architecture in two seasons.
The purpose of this study is to expand the field of recognizing and introducing the cultural resources of our country through analysis and introduction of geometric patterns of these two buildings according to the subtleties hidden in the geometric patterns used in these mosques as well as discovering the mystery hidden in them. The questions we are trying to answer are 1- how to define the criteria of the geometric patterns of these two mosques by comparing the geometric patterns used in the comprehensive mosques of Kerman and Yazd?
2- Considering the restoration, reconstruction and annexation of parts to the buildings of both Yazd and Kerman mosques, what are the most important stylistic features preserved in the geometric designs of both mosques during different historical periods?
Using descriptive-analytical method and conducting library research in the field of architectural arrays of these two buildings and field research, this study has evaluated and comparatively compared the geometric patterns of these two buildings of the Iranian architectural index.
The method of data collection is documentary and based on visual field research (photography), and according to the value of observations, perceptual mapping method has been used to explain the visual stages.
The research findings show that considering the precedence of construction of Yazd Jami Mosque over Kerman Jami Mosque, the possibility of modeling and adopting this mosque by the artists of Kerman Jami Mosque seems reasonable.
The construction of both the Yazd and the Kerman mosques did not only include a historical period, but also different periods. Each of these two parts has been built over time by several founders. The Ilkhanid, Timurid, Muzaffarid, Safavid and the Qajar governments have played a role in completing parts of these two buildings, but Zandieh-era motifs are visible in the entirety of the Kerman Jami Mosque.
The main features of the designs in the Yazd Jami Mosque are mostly based on patriarchal and Timurid features. The predominant style of geometric designs in the Kerman Jami Mosque is Ilkhanid and Muzaffarid.
The geometric designs of Yazd and Kerman Jami Mosques have differences and similarities, among which there are many more similarities than the differences that can be considered as the common spirit of their geometric designs.
Since both mosques were built in different periods, one cannot expect a geometric pattern from a historical period in both mosques. But it is interesting that the main spirit and essence of the geometric designs of both patriarchal mosques, the Ilkhanid essence, in later periods with the knowledge that has reached them from previous masters has been preserved.
Subsequent masters have tried to present harmony and unity with the previous designs and have practically followed in their footsteps. And the observer of these geometric patterns practically does not notice the inconsistency in the patterns which is the result of obvious differences in design.
If we want to evaluate the geometric designs of these two buildings in terms of style, the Yazd Jami Mosque is more inspired by patriarchal and Timurid architecture, which is close to the Azeri style, and in terms of geometric designs is more "logical and complex" than the Kerman Jami Mosque. On the other hand, the geometric designs of the Kerman Jami Mosque are mostly inspired by patriarchal and Muzaffarid architecture.
Moreover, in terms of form indicators, geometric patterns are valuable examples in the field of "expression of emotional states" in form and color.

Keywords


Ahmadi Maleki, Rahman, Symbolic Forms and Roles in Iranian Mosques "Eternal Heritage Endowment Magazine, No. 22, 2008.
Anbari Yazdi, Faezeh (2015) Geometry and Patterns, Volume 1, Fifth Edition, Tehran: Textbook Publishing Company.
Abui Mehrrizi, Mohammad Reza, The Cultural Life of the Kakoyeh Family, New Historical Studies, No. 1, 2005.
Beyrami, Reyhaneh, Farrokhfar, Farzaneh, Kharazian, Laleh, A Study of Kufi Inscriptions of Kerman Grand Mosque, The Second National Conference on Applied Research in Geography and Tourism, Tehran, Comprehensive University of Applied Sciences, March 13, 2015.
Daneshvar, Mohammad. Bastani Parizi, Mohammad Ebrahim (2008) Old neighborhoods of Kerman, Kerman: Kerman Studies Center.
Ebrahimpour, Roh Angiz, A Case Study of Mosques: A Case Study of Kerman Grand Mosque (Mozaffariyeh) ", 3rd International Congress of Contemporary Architecture and Urban Planning in the Middle East, Tehran, Shahid Beheshti University, May 2, 2017.
Ghamari, Masoud, Heidari, Abbas, Nowruzi, Maliheh, Study and study of the decoration of the entrance of the Kerman Grand Mosque, International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture and Sustainable Urban Development, Tabriz, Islamic Azad University, May 10, 2013.
Golabzadeh, Seyed Mohammad Ali (2010) Kerman in the Mirror of Tourism, Kerman: Kerman Studies Center Publications.
Hali, Seyed Akbar (1986) Knots and Arches in Islamic Architecture Volume One, Tehran: Mehr Printing House.
Hajizadeh Bastani, Karim, Aesthetics and Symbolic Values of the Inscriptions of Yazd Grand Mosque, Archaeological Research of Iran, No. 18, Eighth Volume, pp. 192 175, 2017.
Hager, Peter J.Corbin. Nancy C. (1997) Desiqnina & Deliverinq: Scientific, Technical, And Managerial Presentation, New York.
 
Kazempour, Mehdi. Mohammadzadeh, Mehdi. Comparative study of Shiite symbolic motifs of the tomb of Sheikh Safi al Din Ardabili with the Yazd Grand Mosque ", Art Architecture, No. 44, 2017.
Khezri, Seyed Hashem Dargahi, Zein Al Abedin (2005) Art and Architecture of Mosques, Secretariat of the Supreme Headquarters for Coordination and Supervision of Cultural and Artistic Centers of Mosques, Volume 2, First Edition, Tehran: Rasanesh Publishing.
Maher Al Naghsh, Mahmoud (1983) Design and Execution of Role in Iranian Tile, Islamic Period, Third Knotting Office, First Edition, Tehran: Reza Abbasi Museum.
Maher Al Naghsh, Mahmoud (2011) Tile and its application, Poor Roshan, fifth edition, Tehran.
Nosrati, Massoud, Yazd Grand Mosque A valuable collection of Quranic inscriptions "Golestan Honar, No. 87, pp. 26 20, 2001.
Pope, Arthur (1373) Iranian Architecture, translated by Gholamreza Sadri Afshar, third edition, Tehran: Farhangan Publications.
Shayestehfar, Mahnaz, Shakarpour Shahriyar, Comparison of the design and role of Zylobafi Meybod and Yazd Comprehensive Prostration, Islamic Art Studies, No. 11, pp. 25 42, 2009.
Tahani, Assadollah, Eghdami, Hamed, Mohajeri, Atta, Explanation and study of Yazd Grand Mosque, International Conference on Human, Civil, Civil and Urban, Tabriz: Center for Strategic Studies in Architecture and Urban Planning, June 15, 2015.
Yazdi Writer, Ahmad Ibn Hussein (2007) The New History of Yazd, by Iraj Afshar, First Edition, Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications.