A Study on the Evolution of the Structure of Safavid Album Prefaces

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Assistant Professor, Art and Architecture Faculty, Yazd University, Yazd

10.22070/negareh.2021.14498.2771

Abstract

As the evidence shows, writing preface to Persian works is a tradition that goes back to the first literary or historical works after Islam. With the emergence of various literary and historical forms such as a collection of poems, memoirs or dynastic and royal histories, preface writing also evolved and according to the subject or other political and religious factors, different parts of it changed. On the other hand, as a result of the great attention of the Ilkhanids and subsequent governments, especially the Jalayrians, to art and artists, numerous literary and historical works were made and illustrated. The Timurids, by following their example, tried to develop and flourish these arts as much as possible. In the meantime, a new genre called the album, consisting of calligraphic pieces and images, was created; the oldest example of which belongs to the era of Shahrokh and to Prince Baysonghor Mirza. Based on this, it seems that it was the Timurids who first came up with the idea of making an album. Since then, and over the next four centuries, many albums have been made up of calligraphy pieces, images, or a combination of both. Likewise, it seems that adding a preface to the beginning of the album is also a Timurid innovation. Because the first known preface of the album, which is detached from its album and written by Sharaf al-din Ali Yazdi, is the preface of the album of Khajeh Abd al-Qader, a famous musician and calligrapher in the courts of Jalayerians and Timurids. The preface was probably written between 807 AH and 822 AH. The fact that, on what basis Sharaf al-Din Ali Yazdi wrote this preface, and whether or not it had a prior pattern are somewhat obscure to us. The second existing album preface was written with a relatively long distance from Yazdi's preface, i.e. in 897 AH, which was also separated from its album and is preserved in the collection of essays of its author, Khajeh Abdollah Morvarid. After that, there are no other album prefaces until the first preface of the Safavid album, that is, the preface of Dust Mohammad (951 AH). In the Safavid period, we see a coherent tradition of preface writing on albums, which lasted more than a hundred years. Like the literary and historical prefaces, these prefaces were changed under the influence of many factors, and their structure gradually became more complex, and new structural components were added to them. The aim of the present study is to determine the evolution of the structural components of the album prefaces of the Safavid era. In fact, the main issue of the present study is that over time, in what ways has the structure of the album prefaces of the Safavid era changed, and what is the nature and extent of these changes? To answer the main question and achieve the purpose of the research, descriptive-analytical method was used and to better explain, adaptation and content analysis were used. The method of collecting materials is library-based. The statistical population of the study, in addition to the two Timurid prefaces, namely the preface of Ab al-Qader Maraghi and Mir Ali Shirnavaei, includes eight Safavid prefaces, which are the preface of Dust Mohammad, the preface of Qutb al-din Mohammad Qisi khwan, preface to Shahqoli Caliph Mohrdar’s Album, the preface of Malik Daylami and the prefaces of Shams al-din Mohammad Wasfi, Mohammad Mohsen, Mirak Salehi and Morteza Qoli Shamlu, which were probably written on personal Albums. The explanation is as follows: first, the possible effects and received influences, the general structure of the literary and historical prefaces and the prefaces of the Timurid albums are examined. Then, by examining the content of the prefaces of the Safavid albums, their structural components are extracted and matched. Then, through quantitative content analysis, the rate of change of the main structures of the prefaces (Praise, Argument, History and Description) over time is analyzed. The results show that the authors of the album prefaces in the Safavid period came up with a new design. Two structural components (art history and description of the album) were added to connect the preface with the album as much as possible. In fact, the history of structural changes in the Safavid album prefaces is the history of solving the problem of this connection and establishing a balance between these two components. Finally, the combination and balance of these two components were concluded in the preface of Morteza Qoli Shamlu; a preface that solved this problem, not through the equality of these two components, but through the use of literary and linguistic figures. The personalization of the albums has not been without effect on the fading of some components, such as philosophy of art and its legitimacy, and the importance of others, such as the description of the album.

Keywords


Abdi Beg Shirazi, Khwajeh Zeyn al-Abedin (1977), Ayʾin Eskandari, by Ali Shafaei, Moscow: Danesh
Bassak, Hasan (1399/ 2020), “The Stylistics of Preludes and Praises in the Iraqi Style of Prose; Focus on Eminent Texts,” Journal of Stylistic of Persian Poem and Prose (Bahar-e-Adab) Vol. 13 , no. 2 (48); pp. 1-22.
Danishpazhuh, Muhammad Taqi (1359/1980), “Muraqqaʿ sazi va jung nivisi,” In Farkhunda Payam: Yadegarnama-ye Ustad Doktor Gholamhusayn Yusufi, Mashhad: Danishgah-i Mashhad: pp. 148-229.
Ghasemi Hosseyn, Rahmanifar Sima (1390/ 2011), “Study Of The Historiography Objectives And Historian Methods For Legitimacy To A Series Of Chronicles And Religious Prefaces From The Period Of First Shah Abbas To The End Of Safavid State,” TarikhFall , Vol. 6 , no. 22; pp. 119-139.
Hassanein, Azadeh (1395/ 2016), “Comparative Study of ‘Golestan-e Honar’ and ‘Manaqeb-e Honarvaran,’”  Journal Of Historical Studies Of Islam,  Fall, Vol. 8 , No. 30; pp. 81-99.
Kusha, Kefayat (2004), “Persian Artists Immigration to India in Safavid Era,” Ayeneh-ye Miras, no. 26; pp. 26-57
Laurence Binyon, J. V. S Wilkinson, Basil Gray (1933). Persian Miniature Painting: including a critical and descriptive catalogue of the miniatures exhibited at Burlington House, January-March, 1931, Tran. Muhammad Iranmanesh, Tehran: Amirkabir
Mayil Heravi, Najib (1372/ 1993), Ketab Arai dar Tamaddun-I Islami, Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi
Mirzaee Mehr, Ali Asghar (1391/ 2012), “Comparative Study on Gulistani Honar and Menaqib Honarvaran (Painting and Painters Part),” Fin Art: Visual Arts, Fall, Vol. 4, no. 49; pp. 45-56
Morvarid Kermani, Shahab al-Din Abdollah (1398/ 2019), Munshʿat Abdollah Murvarid, Correction by Asraʾ al-Sadat Ahmadi, Tehran: Majlis Shora Islami
Naʿini Khoddari, Saʿed (1390/ 2011), “Prefaces of Some Albums,” Oraq Atiq, no. 2: 13-80
Najafipour, Akram (1396/ 2017), Comparative Study Of Prefaces of Dust Muhammad Gvashany and Qutb Al-Din Muhammad, Motaleate Tatbighi Honar, Spring-Summer, Vol. 7 , no. 13; pp. 149-164.
Nakhshabi, Zya al-Din (1372/ 1993), Tuti Nameh, by Fathollah Mojtabaee and Gholam Ali Arya, Tehran: Manoochehri
Nizam al-Molk Tusi, Abu ʿAli Hosseyn ibn ʿAli (1380/ 2001), Syar al-Moluk (Syasat Nameh), Tehran: Bongah-I Tarjomeh va Nashr Kitab.
PourJavadi, Nasr al-lah (1383/ 2004), “Preface: Assembly of Writers and Reader with a view on the Prefaces of Kashf al-Mahjoob of Hajviri and Jame al-Hekmatayn of Naser Khosrow,” Ayeneh-ye Miras, Winter, no. 27; pp. 123-140.
Quinn, Sholeh A. (1387/ 2008), “Historiography of Safavid Prefaces,” Trans. By Farshid Nowroozi, Nameh Tarikh Pajoohan, Winter, no. 16; pp. 82-116
Quinn, Sholeh A. (1387/ 2008), Historical Writing During the Reaign of Shah Abbas: Ideology, Imitation and Legitimacy in Historical Texts of Safavid Era, trans. By Mansur Sefatgol, Tehran: University of Tehran Press.
Rahimi, Hanif; Shirazi, Ali Asghar; Marasi, Mohsen (1395/ 2016), “A Study of Dust Mohammad’ s Preface to Bahram Mirza’ s Album Based on Analytical Historical Sociology,”  Journal Of Visual And Applied ArtsSpring-Summer, Vol. 9 , no. 17; pp. 53-69.
Rahimi, Hanif; Shirazi, Ali Asghar; Marasi, Mohsen (1396/ 2018), “A Defense of Painting: Analysis of Qutb al-Din Muhammad’ s Preface to Shah Tahmasb’ s Album with an Analytical Historical Sociology Approach,” Negarehsummer, Vol. 13 , no. 46; pp. 4-15.
Rʾana Hosseini, Karamat (1366/ 1987), “Preface of the Album of Shams al-Din Muhammad Mirak,” Farhang Iran Zamin, no. 27: pp. 73-76
Rashtyani, Goudarz (1390/ 2011), “Writing Prefaces of Historical Texts of Afshary: Contentious and Changes in a Historical Tradition,” Tarikhnegari va Tarikhnegari, Fall and Winter, Vol. 90, no. 8; pp. 37-61
Roxburgh, David J. (2001), Prefacing the Image: The Writing Art History in Sixteenth-century Iran, Leiden; Boston; Koln: Brill.
Ryahi Zamin, Zahra, Amiri, Leyla (1397/ 2018), “A Study on the Structure of the Preface of Mathnavies up to the Seven/ Fourteen Century,” Pajooheshhaye Adabi, Spring, no. 59; pp. 33-62
Seki, Yoshifusa (1381/ 2002), “Preface of Qotb al-Din Muhammad Qisi Khan to Shah Tahmasp Album,” Nameh Baharestan, Fall and Winter, no. 6; pp. 309-316
Sotudeh, Gholamreza, Najafzadeh Barfroush, Muhammad Baqer (1369/ 1990), Eulogy in Persian Literature, Tehran: Jahad Daneshgahi
Thackston, McIntosh Wheeler (2001), Album Prefaces and Other Documents on the History of Calligraphers and Painters, Leiden; Boston; Koln: Brill.
Yazdi, Sharaf al-Din (1388/ 2009), Monshʿat, Critical Correction, Iraj Afshar and Muhammad Reza Abui Mehrizi, Tehran: Soraya
Yves Porter (2000), “From the Theory of the Two Qalams to the Seven Principles of Painting: Theory, Terminology, and Practice in Persian Classical Painting,” Muqarnas, no. 17; pp. 1909-118