Typology, Classification and Analysis of Headstones of Irans’ North West in Islamic Era (Case Study: from the Ilkhanid to the End of the Safavid Era)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD Student in Archeology, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Mohaghegh Ardabili University, Ardabil Province. Iran.

2 PhD Student in Archeology, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Mohaghegh Ardabili University, Ardabil Province, Iran.

3 PhD student in Archeology, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Babolsar University, Mazandaran Province, Iran.

10.22070/negareh.2020.4881.2338

Abstract

Headstones have been one of the inseparable thoughts of death among all the communities from old times to nowadays that were used as an essential tool for their visual and spiritual aspects. However, there are various points of view in creating headstones and their relative sign fields in different societies. This phenomenon had a special place in Islamic- Iranian's attitude and is created in different forms and decorative figurations. The North West area of Iran is one of the finest places for such materials and this research was done to identify, classify and analyze them in order to find answers to these following questions: what are the typology and forms of Iran's North West's headstones ? To which areas does the analysis of cognitive foundations of headstones in Iran's North West refer? How many categories may be designated for the decorative figurations of these headstones? This research is using descriptive- analytical method along with several documents and field studies for recording some Islamic-era graveyards of Iran's North West. The result of this research indicates that regarding the shape of placement, headstones are divided into three forms: horizontal, vertical and hybrid with different kinds. Some of the headstones are rooted in middle - Asian societies and have various concepts in terms of decorative arrays. Prime examples are: a) human, b) herbal, c) animal, d) geometric- symbolic, e) objects and tools. Currently, many of these monuments are damaged by mankind and nature, and just a few of them are in fine shape. Headstones are among the components of funerals and were used as an identification and indicator of date of death. It is also a great place to transfer concepts of public culture. Headstones are affected by geographical, political, social and cultural features of each area. They have a special place for mankind’s beliefs and are affected by attitudes of different people of each area. Islamic-era headstones have various decorative arrays and appearances, which present them as a great collection for studying archaeology, history, culture, art and politics of different places as well as a source of knowledge about social beliefs of people for researchers. Studying headstones from different regions of Iran indicates that they have an important place in Islamic- Iranian culture. Headstones of each region have their own specialties and Islamic- era headstones of Iran’s North West have a lot of variety among them.
The North West area of Iran in Islamic era had a good potentiality for shaping headstones fitting the religion beliefs due to existence of different groups of people. Thus, in this area, there are so many graveyards left from different periods of Islamic era, and a huge, diverse spectrum of headstones was shaped in them. However, there has been no global research in terms of appearances and figurations around typology and classification of Islamic headstones of Iran's North West region so far. Studies on headstones in terms of archeology, anthropology, linguistics, arts and other sciences are important and they need an intense, coherent focus. Accordingly, this research studies headstones in different areas of Azerbaijan in addition to classification and typology of headstones based on two aspects of appearance and decorative figuration. The elegance and variety of form and shape of the headstones of Iran's North West in Islamic era were fascinating to many researchers and visitors for a long time. However, headstones were less focused on in terms of appearances, used array and cognitive foundations, and they deserve more comprehensive and wider researches to become a specific science study field in other cases for classifying these monuments. The research has been edited based on qualitative approach and descriptive-analytical research method, and information was gathered by library and field studies. For this purpose, about 30 Islamic- era graveyards in Iran's North West were studied. That way due to scattered graveyards in the North West area, lack of registration information, and unknown samples by relevant organizations, through field studies some of monuments were recognized in Meshkin Shahr, Khalkhal, Nir, Ardabil, Sarein, Maragheh, Varzaghan, Bostanabad, Tabriz, Marand, Ahar, Miandoab and Salmas counties. In next phase, these data were classified and analyzed with qualitative methods and comparative study methods. Moreover, in this research, some pictures of graveyards in Sosava, Bijagh, Gal, Varzaghan, Sefidabad, Some’eh del and Salmas villages were selected and subsequently, schemes and figurations were designed and classified based on analyses from Corel and AutoCad software’s. In the end, we achieved a relative typology of figurations and appearances of North West headstones in Islamic era.

Keywords


Afghahi, Maryam, (2008), A Study of Tombstones in the Safavid Period with Emphasis on the Capitals of this Period, Master Thesis in Handicrafts, Supervisors Mehrangiz Mazaheri and Mohsen Golestani, Al-Zahra University.
Ağasıoğlu, F., (2013). DAŞBABA TÜRKÜN DAŞ YADDAŞI, Baki.
Ahmadzadeh, Farid, Hashem Hosseini and Hamed Noursi, (2018), a study on recognizing the themes and motifs of the tomb of Goran tribe in the city of Islamabad Gharb, Visual Arts, No. 5, pp. 92-79.
Aksoy, M., (2017). Bitlis ve Ahlat'ta Koç-Koyun Başlı Mezar Taşları, Kümbetler ve Damgalar. Turk yourdu, 35-38.
ALYILMAZ, C. and ALYILMAZ, S., (2017), IĞDIR VE ÇEVRESİNDEKİ KOÇ HEYKELLİ MEZAR TAŞLARININ ÜZERLERİNDEKİ ARAP HARFLİ YAZITLAR. Türk Dünyası Dil ve Edebiyat Dergisi, (43), pp.305-345.
ARSLAN, A.S., (2017). “TAŞLAR KONUŞUR”: TÜRK MEZAR TAŞLARININ BİÇİM DİLİ. Uluslararası Türkçe Edebiyat Kültür Eğitim (TEKE) Dergisi, 6(3), pp.1923-1937.
Baykara, T., (1993). Asya Türk Kültürünün Bir Unsuru Olarak Mezar Taşı. Vakıflar Haftası, s. 127-131.
Berkli, Y., (2007). Erzurum’da Yeni Bulunan Haç Motifli Koç Heykelinin Düşündürdükleri. Atatürk Üniversitesi Türkiyat Araştırmaları Enstitüsü Dergisi, 14(34), pp.215-232.
Berkli, Y., (2012). Azerbaycan-Bakü’de Bulunan İnsan Heykel Biçimli Mezar Taşları ve Orta Asya-Azerbaycan-Anadolu İlişkisi. Türk Kültürü ve Hacı Bektaş Velî Araştırma Dergisi, (61).
Demirel, F., (2008). Besni mezar taşları (Doctoral dissertation, Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü).
Efandiof, Rasim, (1986), Stone plastic Art of Azerbaijan, Baky.
Effendioff, Rasim, (2013), The Stones Speak, translated by Mohammad Ali Arshafar, Tabriz: Deniz.
Ertan, D.A.Ş.,(2010), Bozdoğan Mezar Taşları. Sanat Tarihi Dergisi, 19(2), pp.109-127.
Godard, A. (1965). The Art of Iran: New York, Frederick A. Praeger Publishers, 277, 283-284.
Hall, James, (2001), Dictionary of Symbols in East and West Art, translated by Roghayeh Behzadi, Tehran: Contemporary Culture.
Hashari Tabrizi, Mullah Mohammad Amin, (1992), Roza Athar, edited by Aziz Dolatabadi, Tabriz: Sotoudeh.
Helen Brand, Robert, (2001), Islamic Architecture, Form of Function and Meaning, translated by Baqer Ayatollahzadeh Shirazi, Tehran: Rozaneh.
Karbalaei Tabrizi, Hafez Hussein, (1965), Rawdat al-Jannan and Janat al-Jannan, Jafar Sultan al-Qara'i, Tehran: Book Translation and Publishing Company.
Kargar, Mohammad Reza, (1993), Islamic tombs and its cultural base in northwestern Iran-Azerbaijan, Master Thesis in Archeology, Supervisor Jaber Ansari, Tarbiat Modares University.
Khazaei, Mohammad, (2001), The role of the lion of Imam Ali, Book of the Month of Art, pp. 37-39.
Kleiss, W. (1969,( Berich Uber zwei Erkundungsfahrten in Nordwest – Iran, Archaeologische Mitteilungen Aus Iran, 1-54.
Mirjafari, Hossein, Bazaz Dastforosh, Mehdi, (2012), Bilankooh Tomb of Tabriz, Historical Research, Volume 48, Number 14, pp. 22-1.
Moharrampour Alaviani, Mehrdad, (2003), Study and study of tombstones in Maragheh city in the Islamic period, Master Thesis in Archeology, Supervisor Susan Bayani, Azad University, Central Tehran Branch.
Mostofi, Hamdollah, (1957), Nazhat al-Qulub, Mohammad Dabirsiyaghi, Tehran: Tahoori Library.
Mousavi Kouhpar, Seyed Mehdi, Hamid Khanali and Javad Neyestani, (2015), Tombstones Demonstrated the Unity of Different Islamic Religions in Iran Typology of Classification and Study of Cradle Array Tomb Arrays, Quarterly Journal of Islamic History Research, Volume 5, Number 20, pp. 133-152.
Parvin, Samad, (2016), Archaeological study of Islamic tombstones in Meshkinshahr city Case study of Onar cemetery, Master Thesis in Archeology, Supervisor Behrouz Afkhami, Mohaghegh Ardabili University.
Pope, Arthur, (2011), Iranian Architecture, translated by Gholam Hossein Sadri Afshar, Tehran: Bayat.
Rezalo, Reza and Yahya Airmloo, (2014), Horse burial ritual among Scythian tribes Case study of Khorramabad Meshginshahr cemetery, Historical Sociology, Volume 6, Number 3, pp. 144-113.
Samari, Maryam, (2016), Tombstones of Ardabil, Master Thesis in Archeology, Supervisor Reza Rezaloo, Mohaghegh Ardabili University.
Shayestehfar, Mahnaz, (2009), Decorations of the inscriptions on the tombstones of Sheikh Safi and its adaptation to the diners of Gorgan, Book of the Month of Art, No. 134, pp. 81-74.
Shayestehfar, Mahnaz, Golmoghanizadeh Asl, Queen,(2002), Inscriptions on the exterior of the tomb of Sheikh Safi al-Din Ardabili, Social Sciences and Humanities, Volume 19, Number 1, pp. 103-83.
Shokouhi Brothers, Sirus, (1992), Final Report of Azerbaijani Inscriptions, University of Tabriz.
Tabrizi, Mohammad Kazem Ibn Mohammad, (2009), Manzar al-Awliya, edited by Mir Hashem Mohaddes, Tehran: Library of the Islamic Consultative Assembly.
Tanavoli, Parviz, (1975), Fars Dairy Carpets, Tehran: University of Tehran.
Vandenberg, Louis, (1969), Archeology of Ancient Iran, translated by Isa Behnam, Tehran: University of Tehran.
YILDIRIM, Y., (2016). KARAMAN MEZAR TAŞLARI TİPOLOJİSİ. Şehir Dergisi, Sayı: 18, PP. 97-129.